Personally, I like the Halloween pets better when they were just... dressed up as random things. The Jubjub isn't the only pet even now that's just 'dressed up' - the Halloween Bruce, Peophin/Kobrat(..granted, they're old as hell), and well, my personal favorite Halloween pet:
![Image](http://images.neopets.com/pets/happy/shoyru_halloween_baby.gif)
Obviously just a red Shoyru in a costume. Personally, I think that's cute. I love the pets that look like other.. things too (like the uni as the Nightsteed - awesome.) but I think making the Jubjub just.. a punkin takes something away from it. I think its shell cracking and you seeing the real Jubjub underneath since it was just.. dressed up for Halloween makes it adorable.
Anyway, my thoughts.
I hate all starry pets, I really do, but at least the stars aren't obnoxiously placed like they tend to be with starry pets. It's tolerable.
And I strangely like the strawberry one. I like the dollop of green on its head. Cuuuuute. Maybe overkill with the seeds though. Of course, most of the food pets... just scare me.